Top Rated Auto Insurance in Australia 2026: Complete Online Guide
Finding the right car insurance in Australia is getting harder every year. Premiums are rising, new insurers are entering the market, and every brand claims to offer “the best” cover. The risk? You either overpay for cover you don’t need or choose a cheap policy that leaves you badly exposed when you have an accident.
This guide to top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026 is designed to solve that problem.
You’ll learn:
- How Australian car insurance works in 2026
- Which insurers are consistently top rated and worth shortlisting
- How to compare policies properly (not just on price)
- What really affects your premiums
- How to lower costs without losing essential protection
By the end, you’ll be able to confidently choose a top rated auto insurance policy for 2026, get competitive online quotes, and know exactly what you’re paying for.
How Auto Insurance Works in Australia
Before you compare the top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026, it’s crucial to understand the basic types of cover and what they do (and don’t) include.
The Four Main Types of Car Insurance
In Australia, car insurance generally falls into four categories:
Compulsory Third Party (CTP / Green Slip)
- Legally required in every state/territory
- Covers injury or death to other people if you cause an accident
- Does not cover damage to vehicles or property
Comprehensive Car Insurance
- The highest level of cover
- Covers damage to your own vehicle and other people’s property
- Usually covers theft, fire, storm, hail, vandalism, and more
- Often includes optional extras like hire car and roadside assistance
Third Party Property Only
- Covers damage you cause to other people’s vehicles or property
- Does not cover damage to your own car
Third Party, Fire and Theft
- Everything in Third Party Property
- Plus cover if your car is stolen or damaged by fire
Here’s a quick comparison:
| Cover Type | Your Car Damage | Other Cars/Property | Theft | Fire | Required by Law? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CTP / Green Slip | No | No (injury only) | No | No | Yes |
| Third Party Property Only | No | Yes | No | No | No |
| Third Party, Fire and Theft | Theft/Fire only | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Comprehensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
For most drivers looking at top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026, comprehensive cover is the main focus, especially for newer or higher-value cars.
Key Terms You Need to Know
When comparing top rated policies, you’ll constantly see these terms:
- Premium – what you pay for the policy (monthly or yearly)
- Excess – the amount you pay when you make a claim
- Market value – what your car is worth at the time of a claim
- Agreed value – a fixed amount you and the insurer agree on
- No Claim Bonus (NCB) or Rating – discounts for claim-free years
- Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) – the legal document explaining what’s covered and what’s excluded
Always read the PDS before you buy. Top rated auto insurance is not just about star ratings; it’s about how well the cover matches your actual needs.
 |
| Top Rated Auto Insurance in Australia 2026 |
What “Top Rated Auto Insurance” Really Means in 2026
“Top rated” can mean many things, depending on who is doing the rating. For top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026, these are the most important criteria to consider.
1. Customer Satisfaction and Claims Experience
- How quickly are claims processed?
- Are repairs managed smoothly?
- Do customers feel they are treated fairly?
- Are repairers high quality and guaranteed?
Look at:
- ProductReview.com.au scores
- Complaint data from the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA)
- Consumer group reviews (e.g., CHOICE)
2. Value for Money
A “cheap” policy can be expensive if it excludes common risks. A top rated policy should:
- Offer competitive premiums
- Include strong standard benefits
- Provide optional extras that add real value, not just marketing fluff
3. Policy Features and Flexibility
Strong policies tend to include or offer:
- New-for-old replacement for new cars (within certain years/km)
- Choice of repairer (or at least transparent repairer policies)
- Lifetime repair guarantees
- Windscreen/glass cover (often with reduced or no excess)
- Hire car after theft or not-at-fault accident
- Genuine parts on new cars
4. Financial Strength and Reputation
You want an insurer that can actually pay claims, not just advertise well. Look at:
- Large, well-established brands
- Providers backed by major insurers or financial groups
- History of operating in Australia
5. Digital Tools and Online Experience
In 2026, top rated auto insurance in Australia should give you:
- Instant online quotes
- Mobile app to manage policies and claims
- Online claim lodgement and tracking
- Digital PDS and policy documents
Consistently Top Rated Auto Insurers in Australia
I can’t see into the future, but based on consistent performance, industry awards, and customer reviews up to late 2024, the following brands are regularly rated highly and are worth shortlisting for auto insurance in Australia 2026. Always check current reviews and awards when you’re ready to buy.
(Order below is alphabetical, not a ranking.)
AAMI
One of Australia’s most recognisable brands.
Typical strengths:
- Wide range of cover options, including comprehensive and third party
- Strong online quoting and policy management
- Multi-policy discounts if you bundle home, contents, or other insurance
Often known for:
- Flexible excess options
- Optional hire car cover
- Roadside assistance options (depending on state and product)
Allianz
A global insurance giant with a strong presence in Australia.
Common benefits:
- Comprehensive cover with a solid reputation
- Optional extras such as rental car after an accident
- Good range of discounts in some cases (e.g., low km, security devices)
Often appealing to:
- Drivers wanting an established, financially strong brand
- Those who prefer comprehensive, well-documented policies
Budget Direct
Frequently awarded for value and competitive premiums.
Key features often include:
- Very competitive pricing for many drivers
- Online-only or online-focused quoting process
- Multi-policy and no-claims discounts
Good for:
- Budget-conscious drivers who still want solid cover
- People comfortable managing their policy online
NRMA Insurance (NSW/ACT & some other regions)
NRMA is a popular name, especially in NSW and the ACT.
What they’re commonly known for:
- Strong roadside assistance options (via NRMA membership)
- Comprehensive policies with optional extras
- Local presence and brand trust in some regions
Often attractive to:
- Families and long-term policyholders
- Drivers who value roadside assistance bundled with insurance
RACV, RACQ, RAA and Other Motoring Club Insurers
State-based motoring clubs often provide highly rated cover:
- RACV (Victoria)
- RACQ (Queensland)
- RAA (South Australia)
- RACT (Tasmania)
- RAC (WA)
Typical strengths:
- Strong local knowledge and networks
- Member discounts and benefits
- Good customer service scores in many regions
Youi
Youi is known for asking detailed questions and tailoring premiums.
Strengths:
- Personalised risk-based pricing (good if you’re a lower-risk driver)
- Flexible coverage based on how and where you drive
- Strong focus on customer service and claims outcomes
Best suited to:
- Drivers whose risk profile is better than average
- People willing to spend a bit more time on the quote process
Tip: When you’re searching for top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026, create a shortlist of 4–6 brands (including at least one motoring club insurer and one value provider like Budget Direct). Then get quotes from each.
How to Compare Top Rated Auto Insurance Policies in 2026
A top rated insurer isn’t always the best for you. Here’s a simple process to compare car insurance in 2026:
Step 1: Decide the Level of Cover You Really Need
Ask yourself:
- What is my car worth today?
- Could I afford to replace it myself if it was written off?
- Do I park on the street or in a secure garage?
- Is theft or vandalism common in my suburb?
General guide:
- New or high-value car: Comprehensive is usually best
- Older, low-value car: Third Party Property or Third Party, Fire and Theft may be enough
Step 2: Gather Quotes From At Least 3–5 Insurers
Use a mix of:
- Comparison websites (to get a quick overview)
- Direct insurer websites (some deals are not on comparison sites)
- Motoring club insurers (RACV, RACQ, etc.)
Call to action examples:
- Get a Quote Online from each shortlisted insurer
- Compare Policies Side by Side using your own spreadsheet
Record for each quote:
- Annual premium (and monthly premium if you prefer)
- Excess amount
- Type of cover (comprehensive, third party, etc.)
- Key included features
- Optional extras and their cost
Step 3: Look Beyond Price
Two policies might cost the same but offer very different protection. Compare:
- New-for-old replacement terms
- Windscreen and glass cover (is excess reduced or waived?)
- Hire car after accident or theft
- Towing and emergency accommodation
- Personal effects cover
- Keys and locks replacement
- Choice of repairer
Top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026 should offer a good balance of these features without excessive exclusions.
Step 4: Check the PDS and Exclusions
Before you buy:
Download the PDS for each policy
Search for terms like “exclusions”, “not covered”, “conditions”
Check:
- Who is allowed to drive? (age limits, named drivers, learner drivers)
- Modifications and accessories
- Use of the car (private, business, rideshare, delivery)
- Off-road use and track days
If something isn’t clear, call or chat with the insurer and get clarification in writing where possible.
Step 5: Make a Shortlist and Choose
Narrow down to 2–3 policies that:
- Provide the cover you need
- Have strong customer and industry ratings
- Offer a competitive price for your risk profile
Then choose the policy that gives you the best overall value, not just the lowest premium.
What Affects Your Auto Insurance Premium in 2026?
When you request quotes for top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026, expect your price to depend on many factors.
Main Pricing Factors
Your age and driving experience
- Young drivers (under 25) pay more
- Very new drivers pay more, regardless of age
Driving history
- Previous accidents and claims
- Traffic infringements (speeding, DUI, etc.)
Location
- Postcode risk (theft, vandalism, accident statistics)
- Weather risks (hail, flood, storm)
Vehicle type
- Make, model, year
- Repair costs and parts availability
- Safety ratings
Use of the vehicle
- Private vs business use
- Rideshare or food delivery
- Annual kilometres driven
Parking arrangements
- Secure garage vs street parking
- At home and at work
Cover options you choose
- Comprehensive vs third party
- Excess amount
- Optional extras (hire car, windscreen, roadside assist, etc.)
Understanding these factors helps you influence your premium without sacrificing quality cover.
How to Lower Your Car Insurance Cost Without Losing Protection
You don’t need to sacrifice quality to pay less for top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026. Try:
1. Adjust Your Excess
- Higher excess = lower premium
- Choose a level you can realistically afford in an emergency
2. Limit Who Can Drive the Car
- Restricting drivers to those over 25 can significantly reduce premiums
- Named-driver only policies can be cheaper than “any driver”
3. Reduce Annual Kilometres
- If you drive less, some insurers offer lower premiums
- Consider “pay-as-you-drive” or low-km policies if available
4. Improve Security
- Park in a locked garage where possible
- Install alarms, immobilisers, and tracking devices (if appropriate)
5. Bundle Policies
- Combine car, home, contents, or other policies with one insurer
- Many top rated insurers offer multi-policy discounts
6. Maintain a Clean Driving Record
- Avoid speeding and traffic infringements
- Keep your no-claim bonus intact by avoiding small claims when it’s cheaper to self-pay
Call to action:
- Check Your Price Now: Get new quotes if your circumstances have changed (moved house, changed job, new parking, fewer kms, etc.).
Special Situations to Consider for 2026
Young Drivers and P-Platers
- Often face very high premiums
- Consider being added as a named driver on a parent’s policy
- Look for insurers that specialise in younger drivers or offer safe-driver rewards
Rideshare and Food Delivery (Uber, Ola, DiDi, Uber Eats, DoorDash, etc.)
- Standard car insurance may not cover commercial use
- You may need business-use or specific rideshare cover
- Always disclose your rideshare or delivery work
Electric Vehicles (EVs) and Hybrids
- Higher repair and parts costs can increase premiums
- Some insurers now offer EV-specific policies or discounts
- Check cover for charging equipment and battery-related issues
Classic and Modified Cars
- Standard policies may not cover high-value modifications
- Look for specialist insurers
- Consider agreed-value policies based on professional valuations
Claims: What to Expect From Top Rated Insurers
When you need to claim, top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026 should make the process as simple and stress-free as possible.
Typical Claim Process
Ensure safety first and call emergency services if required
Collect details at the scene:
- Other driver’s name, phone, licence, registration, insurer
- Photos of damage, position of cars, road conditions
- Witness details, if any
Notify your insurer as soon as possible via phone, app, or online form
Provide required information:
- Your policy details
- Incident description
- Police report number (if applicable)
Assessment and repairs
- Insurer may send an assessor or ask for photos
- You may be directed to an approved repairer
- Top rated insurers often guarantee repairs for life of car ownership
Settlement
- If the car is written off, you’ll receive market or agreed value
- If you’re not at fault and the other driver is identified, you may not pay an excess
Look for insurers with:
- 24/7 claims lodgement
- Clear timeframes and regular updates
- Online claim tracking
Example: How to Structure Your Own Comparison
Use a simple table like this when you compare top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026:
| Feature | Insurer A | Insurer B | Insurer C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual Premium | $ | $ | $ |
| Excess | $ | $ | $ |
| Cover Type | Comp/TP | Comp/TP | Comp/TP |
| New-for-Old Replacement | Yes/No | Yes/No | Yes/No |
| Windscreen Cover (No Excess) | Yes/No | Yes/No | Yes/No |
| Hire Car After Accident | Yes/No | Yes/No | Yes/No |
| Choice of Repairer | Yes/No | Yes/No | Yes/No |
| Roadside Assistance | Yes/No | Yes/No | Yes/No |
| No-Claim Bonus Protection | Yes/No | Yes/No | Yes/No |
This makes it much easier to see which policy offers the best value, not just the lowest price.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the best auto insurance company in Australia in 2026?
There is no single “best” insurer for everyone in 2026. The top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026 will depend on your age, driving history, car type, location, and budget. Some insurers are consistently highly rated for customer service and claims, while others are known for sharp pricing. The right approach is to shortlist several top rated brands, get personalised quotes, read the PDS for each, and then choose the policy that offers the best combination of cover, service, and price for your situation.
How much does car insurance cost in Australia in 2026?
Car insurance premiums in 2026 vary widely. Factors include your age, driving record, postcode, car value, annual kilometres, and chosen cover level. A safe, mature driver with a clean record and a modest car in a low-risk suburb might pay a few hundred dollars a year for comprehensive cover. A younger driver with a high-value car in a higher-risk area could pay several thousand dollars. The only accurate way to know is to get online quotes from multiple top rated insurers and compare.
Do I need both CTP and comprehensive car insurance?
Yes, if you own and drive a registered car, you must have Compulsory Third Party (CTP) insurance (called a Green Slip in NSW). This covers injuries to people, not damage to vehicles or property. Comprehensive car insurance is optional but strongly recommended if you want cover for:
- Damage to your own vehicle
- Damage you cause to other people’s cars or property
- Theft, fire, hail, vandalism and more
Most drivers who want top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026 will have CTP (as required) plus comprehensive cover for full protection.
Is comprehensive car insurance worth it for an older car?
It depends on the value of your car and your financial situation. If your car is worth only a small amount and you could afford to replace it yourself, a cheaper third party policy might be enough. But if the car is still valuable to you and you couldn’t easily afford to replace it, comprehensive cover can still be worthwhile. When you get quotes, compare:
- Annual premium cost
- Market or agreed value of the car
If the annual premium is a large percentage of the car’s value, reconsider whether comprehensive is still good value.
How can I lower my car insurance premium in 2026?
To reduce your premium without losing essential cover, you can:
- Increase your excess to a level you can afford
- Limit drivers to those over 25 and/or named drivers only
- Reduce annual kilometres driven where possible
- Park in a secure garage instead of on the street
- Bundle car insurance with home or contents policies
- Keep a clean driving record and protect your no-claim bonus
It’s also smart to shop around every year. Even top rated insurers may adjust pricing, so a quick comparison can save money while keeping strong cover.
Does my policy cover rideshare or food delivery?
Standard personal-use car insurance often does not cover rideshare (Uber, Ola, DiDi) or food delivery (Uber Eats, DoorDash, etc.). You usually need:
- Business-use cover, or
- A specific rideshare/delivery endorsement or product
If you do any commercial driving, always declare it when you request quotes. Some of the top rated auto insurance providers in Australia 2026 offer tailored options for rideshare drivers, but they will only cover you if they know how you use the car.
Is it safe to buy car insurance online?
Yes. Buying car insurance online from reputable, regulated insurers in Australia is generally safe. Insurers must comply with regulations from ASIC and other authorities. To stay safe:
- Only use official insurer websites or trusted comparison sites
- Check the insurer’s ABN and AFSL (Australian Financial Services Licence)
- Read the PDS and Target Market Determination (TMD)
- Keep copies of all confirmations and policy documents
Many of the top rated auto insurance brands now offer better online prices and discounts for buying or managing your policy digitally.
How to Choose the Right Top Rated Auto Insurance in Australia 2026
Choosing top rated auto insurance in Australia 2026 doesn’t have to be confusing or time-consuming.
Follow this simple plan:
- Decide your required cover level (comprehensive vs third party).
- Shortlist 4–6 top rated insurers based on recent reviews and awards.
- Get online quotes from each and record premiums, excess, and key features.
- Read the PDS carefully and check exclusions.
- Compare value, not just price.
- Choose the policy that best fits your needs and budget.
The goal isn’t just to find the “cheapest” deal—it’s to protect your car, your finances, and your peace of mind with a policy you can rely on when it matters most.
Next steps:
- Get Quotes Now from at least three top rated insurers.
- Compare Policies Side by Side using your own comparison table.
- Review Your Cover Annually so you stay protected at a fair price as your life and driving habits change.